Apocrypha - or The Official Version Part II

The Official Version”

Here’s the second section of that letter I wrote to regarding “old materials”. As I mentioned in the first instalment when it first circulated a number of people seemed to feel I was objecting to the study of these remnants of an earlier stage. I hope that you understand that this is not what I intended, nor was it what I wrote. But judge for yourself.

Read More...
Comments

Apocrypha - or The Official Version Part I

“The Official Version”

That follows is drawn from a letter I wrote to an old friend who had been examining, and encouraging the examination of some “old materials”. I
hope you will find it of interest as I think similar issues arise around the questions of the T-Cards, the Method and a number of other issues.

And how could it be otherwise given the range and number of papers, books, exercises, practices etc that were generated by Silo, his school and followers, in the first 4 decades or so of his teaching. Contrast that to the sober two volumes that compose his self-declared “Obras Completas”. Note the name as it is in Spanish not the possibly open-ended “Collected Works” as it was rendered in English but the more definitive, “Complete Works”.

I’m not inferring that this larger corpus should not be attributed to Silo, in an ample sense at least. Nor of course, am I saying one shouldn’t be interested in these semi-orphaned works – after all, I for one am. And any way aren’t we advised to “learn without limits”. Nonetheless, I think it is also important that we understand how, and perhaps even why, Negro distinguished between the works he recognized as part of his official ouvre and all these other works.

Anyway here is the relevant part of the letter I sent. I hope that it proves useful and doesn’t add to any confusion. When it first circulated beyond the person it was originally addressed to a number of people wrote me somewhat incensed that I had “objected” to the study of old materials. I hope that you understand that this is not what I intended, nor was it what I wrote. But judge for yourself.

apocrypha-av

Read More...
Comments